Category: Assemblies

  • Is a Condo Responsible For Property Tax Bills?

    An issue has come up recently that’s produced a flurry of questions from my readers. This topic seems to have created more interest than any other. So… a blog post seems in order.

    Disclaimer

    I have no first-hand knowledge of this situation. Everything I know about what the municipalities are allegedly doing is second and third-hand.

    As always, these are my personal opinions and not legal advice. If your condo is directly affected, you need to get a Mexican legal professional involved.

    Municipal back taxes

    It appears that some municipalities in Jalisco are trying to ferret out property owners who have not paid their property taxes. Presumably, this is to create more revenue for the city coffers.

    Apparently, they’re trying to identify unregistered construction and lots. Unfortunately, it appears that condominium common property has also come under their radar.

    They appear to have hired property assessors to take measurements and photos of property they suspect, and to arrive at a tax value. From this, they seem to be assessing back taxes and penalties. They might be going back as far as ten years.

    At least one condominium that I have heard about has been presented with a large bill.

    Issue #1: a condominium is not a property owner

    In my opinion, the municipality should not invoice a condominium for property taxes – current taxes or back taxes. This is because a condo does not own any property, including the common property.

    The common property is co-owned by all owners. Each owner’s title to their private unit also includes a percentage ownership of all common property. This is clearly set out in each owner’s title document. Article 1001 of the Jalisco Civil Code defines this proportional ownership of common areas and property, and says that such ownership cannot be separated from the individual property.

    From this I believe that if any property taxes are owed, then they’re owed by the owners of the property, and not by the condo. It appears that they might be going after the wrong party to collect these. In my opinion, the tax department is taking this approach because it’s easier to try to collect from a single source than from multiple property owners.

    Issue #2: are back taxes owed?

    The municipal tax department must assess property taxes on any property that’s correctly registered with a public title. All private units in a condo presumably fit this bill. The registered titles for each condo unit specifically include a percentage ownership of the common property.

    When a valuation is placed on a condo unit for tax purposes, one would expect that it would take into account the co-owned portion of the common property that’s clearly defined in the Civil Code and in the title document of the unit.

    If a tax department is now claiming that they failed to do this, then I’d expect that they must prove that their valuation did not include the common property.

    If they can prove that their tax valuations did not include the percentage ownership of the common property, then they can likely recover the lost taxes. However, I fail to see how they can attach penalties to an error that they made.

    My condo has always paid the property tax

    A few condos have an arrangement in their by-laws by which they pay property taxes.

    This might or might not mean that the condo has a tax obligation to the municipality.

    I think it would depend entirely on the wording of the by-laws. Remember not to get bogged down in the semantics of any English translation of your by-laws. This is easy to do. All that matters is what it says in the Spanish version that has been publicly registered.

    Hopefully, such a by-law clause would only appoint the condo administration as an agent to pay owners’ property taxes from the budget and fees as a convenience to the owners. In my opinion, this is a dangerous thing for a condo to do. However, if that’s what your by-laws say, then you likely have this obligation.

    If this applies to your condo, then you need to have a Mexican legal professional examine the wording of your by-laws to determine how liable your condo might be.

    What should we do?

    If your condo has not been presented with a bill for back taxes, then I don’t believe there’s anything for the administration to do other than take part in public discussions, and keep informed on the issue.

    If your condo has been presented with a tax bill, then I think your administration first needs to talk to a Mexican legal professional. I believe that ultimately the goal of the condo should be to shift this tax burden to the individual property owners where it belongs.

    I wouldn’t suggest that the Administrator or the Board pay any such tax bill without the specific agreement of the owners meeting in an extraordinary assembly convened for that purpose.

    If the individual owners receive tax bills, then they can try to dispute this on the basis that the taxes they have been paying included or should have included the common property. They should certainly dispute any penalties. Again, they should get legal help for their particular case.

    If your condo has a by-law section that seems to make the condo responsible for paying property taxes, again I wouldn’t recommend that the administration pay this without legal advice and the specific agreement of the owners.

    If it seems you must pay, hold an extraordinary assembly

    The owners are the title holders of the property in question, and it’s their money the condo would use to pay any such tax bill.

    If the legal professional you meet with believes that money is owed by the condo, then I strongly recommend that you call an extraordinary assembly to ask for the owners’ permission to pay (remember you need 20 days notice).

    The wording of the resolution needs to be carefully considered. I can see two possible approaches:

    The resolution might be to authorise the administration to pay this specific tax bill for the owners, and how it will be funded (such as by a special assessment). If this resolution passes, then the administration should be protected from owners who object to the condo paying this bill.

    Or the resolution could do the opposite, and forbid the administration from paying this specific tax bill, making each owner directly responsible for paying their portion. In a condo with a by-law provision to pay property taxes on the owners’ behalf, this might modify the by-law section with a specific exception.

    Both the choice of approach and the wording needs a legal opinion.

    If the result of the assembly is that the administration should not pay, then I think the condo should have their legal representative present a copy of the registered minutes of the extraordinary assembly to the tax department. After this, they should hopefully turn their collection efforts to the individual owners.

    Community Input

    If you have direct experience with this issue that you feel would add to this post, or if you’ve been advised by a Mexican legal professional, please share your knowledge with the community by posting a comment.

  • How to Handle a Blind-Side at an Assembly

    There are some issues that are complex enough that you want to make sure they pass an assembly vote without needing changes at the assembly. These issues are just too complex to deal with at an assembly.

    Complex wording shouldn’t be thrashed out at an assembly

    For example, let’s say you need to change your condo by-laws.

    By-law changes are a complex issue. They’re a legal document that will govern your condo for years to come. You need to get them right.

    You definitely do not want to make quick changes under the pressure of an assembly. Changes that have not had the benefit of thorough thought and analysis. A hasty rewrite at an assembly can turn out later to have imprecise wording, conflict with another part of the by-laws, or be contrary to the condo law or another law.

    It’s important that these changes be properly thought-out and vetted before the assembly, and that they’re approved without unexpected quick changes that you could regret later.

    You’ve done everything right

    You’ve struck a committee to examine your by-laws, and propose changes. You’ve invited all owners to come to these committee meetings. You’ve send out several stages of draft versions of the proposed by-law changes to the community for the owners’ inspection and feedback. You’ve responded to each owner who took the time to comment. You’ve incorporated some of these owner suggestions. For those you didn’t incorporate, you contacted the owner, talked it over with them, and explained your reasons for not using their suggestion.

    You might have run them past a lawyer to make sure they didn’t contradict the condo law, any other laws, or other parts of the by-laws.

    The result of your lengthy and public process is a set of proposed by-laws that has been thoroughly studied and vetted by the community. Approving them at your upcoming extraordinary assembly should be a smooth and easy process. After all, everyone’s had input, the community has “bought into” the changes, so how could anyone object?

    Reality strikes

    An owner who, for some inexplicable reason known only to themselves, didn’t take part in any of the committee meetings or the public feedback process, but stands up at the assembly and rattles off a list of six or seven changes they demand you make to the proposed by-laws!

    The unfortunate truth about human nature

    In any community, there can be people who’ll be opposed to some of your by-law changes (or any changes), but who won’t take part in your review and feedback process, and who’ll voice their objections for the first time at the assembly.

    I won’t tell you what I think of these people, but the fact is they’re out there. I sincerely hope you don’t have any in your condo!

    Be proactive and have a plan

    If you’ve carried out a thorough and public review, in all likelihood, your vote to adopt the new by-laws as presented will pass with no problems.

    That said, you do need to be prepared for the eventuality of someone trying to thwart the process solely to bolster their own ego. This is a slap in the face to everyone who worked so hard on this project, and to those owners who did give comments and suggestions, but these individuals don’t care about others.

    To help pave the way for dealing with this problem in case it comes up, I recommend that you announce at the beginning of the assembly that:

    • because of the complex nature of the vote, you’ll be following Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised;
    • there’s a time-limit for speakers of five minutes;
    • during discussion, each person can only speak twice to a motion;
    • they cannot speak a second time until everyone else who wishes to speak has had their first opportunity, and their second speech must have new information (cannot be what they already said);
    • rules of decorum will be enforced: if a speaker strays from the topic, makes comments that are a personal attack on another person, questions someone’s motives, refers to someone else by name, is rude, or uses profane language, then the Chair of the Assembly will either sanction them or rescind their speaking privilege.

    If you say this at the beginning, and if no one objects, then these rules are in force for the assembly. If someone does object, have a quick vote – one vote per attendee, majority rules.

    Before the motion to approve the proposed by-laws is made, give a brief introduction. Summarise the process you went through, stressing the amount of time and effort that went into it, the number of people who worked so hard, and the many opportunities every owner had to give their feedback and to voice their concerns or objections. If you used a lawyer, explain that the scrutiny of a lawyer was needed because of the complex nature of the by-laws, and to make sure that they were legal, and that parts didn’t contradict other parts.

    Dealing with changes presented during the motion

    When the motion to adopt the new by-laws comes up, you should then open the motion for discussion before it’s put to a vote as a resolution of the assembly.

    It’s possible that you could have someone there who wants to blind-side the process. They will now bring up one or more changes.

    If someone does stand up with a list of changes, then I suggest you tell them that the time for changes has passed. Explain that there were many opportunities during the lengthy public feedback process to give their concerns and changes, and say that the by-laws are too complex to make changes on-the-fly at an assembly without studying their legality or their impact on the rest of the by-laws.

    Hopefully, they’ll then see reason and sit down. Remember that discussion doesn’t mean that the assembly has to entertain their changes unless they make some sort of formal motion.

    Dealing with an amendment

    If they do propose an amending motion (following the proper procedure as outlined in Robert’s Rules Newly Revised §12. AMEND), then their amendment must be voted on.

    To make this potentially complex process much simpler, insist that each of their proposed changes be stated as a separate amendment, and deal with each one in turn.

    They’ll then make their first motion to amend, citing the first change they want to make.

    For example, assume that the original motion was, “To approve and adopt the proposed by-laws as presented.”

    The amending motion could be, “To approve and adopt the proposed by-laws as presented with a change to the second paragraph of Article 12 as follows, ‘blah blah blah’.”

    A seconder is necessary for the assembly to consider the amendment. If there’s no seconder, the amendment disappears, and you can move on.

    If the amendment is seconded, then the attendees have a right to speak to the amendment before it’s voted on. One or more of the by-law’s supporters (the more the better) should be prepared to make a clear case about why unreviewed changes must not be made. If a committee member is there who knows that the proposed change is illegal, badly worded, or in conflict they should rise and say so.

    When everyone has spoken (no more than twice!), then the amendment is voted on. Just before this vote is taken, the Chair has the right to explain the impact of this change to the assembly, and can restate any concerns about the proposed amendment.

    Remember that proportional voting by condo rights only applies to any final resolution that will be adopted by the assembly.

    Incidental votes of a procedural nature (such as on an amendment) can be a simple one vote per attendee, and the majority carries.

    These motions to amend (and the voting on them) won’t appear in the registered assembly minutes (if you include them, your notario will most likely remove them during the protocolisation process). All the notario wants to see is the wording of the final resolution as it was voted on. He doesn’t care about the process that led up to its final wording.

    Once an amendment has been moved and defeated, it cannot be discussed or brought up again.

    There could be enough people to defeat one or more of these amendments if they already agree with the new by-laws, and understand that off-the-cuff changes to the governing legal document are ill-advised.

    If any amendment passes, you have no choice but to accept it, and the wording of the motion to approve the by-laws will then have the added change for the vote.

    Each new amendment that passes will add some new text onto the end of the original motion.

    Passing an amendment does not make it a resolution of the assembly. The amendment just amends the original motion (to approve the by-laws), and, once all amendments are finished, the amended motion must still be voted on by the assembly before it becomes a resolution of the assembly.

    I realise that this is complicated, but this is such a critical issue that you need to do everything you can to make sure your by-laws are correct. While a deliberative assembly lets someone blind-side you, it also gives you the tools to do everything possible to try to undo any damage they might be causing to the condo through these actions.

    The end result of this series of amendments could be a highly changed motion, a slightly changed motion, or the original motion to approve the by-laws (unchanged).

    Before the final vote takes place on the amended motion, discussion can continue on the motion as amended. This is because the discussion on this motion was put on hold by the amendment process. If the amended resolution contains changes that are harmful, possibly illegal, or damaging to the condo, then you should be prepared to have people stand and say this. If these changes have a significant negative impact on the by-laws, you might now want to lobby to have the amended by-laws defeated for the sake of the condo. Remember that the mover of the original motion can have the last word before the vote.

    This final vote does use condo rights, because this is a resolution of the assembly that’ll be in the minutes and will be binding on all.

    If an amendment passes, and then the amended resolution also passes, this could be unfortunate (depending on the nature of the changes), but you have no choice but to accept the outcome.

    Hopefully, this worst-case scenario is extremely unlikely, and you won’t experience this behaviour in your condo. It is, however, best to be prepared.

  • Conferencing in Meetings and Assemblies

    In the past week or so I’ve received similar questions from different book owners. They were interested in knowing whether it’s proper for a board member to take part in a condo board meeting by videoconference technology (such as Skype).

    If you have board members who are snow birds, or if you have board members who are on vacation (and are dedicated), electronic participation at board and committee meetings can be a useful tool to hold meetings if those physically present wouldn’t form a quorum. Apart from quorum, it also lets these absentees express their views on topics that are important to them. It’s a great enhancement to democracy.

    What does the law say about board meetings?

    The portion of the state civil code that deals with the condo law is silent on how board and committee meetings are to be carried out. There’s nothing I can find in the rest of the civil code to prevent electronic participation, so unless someone can come up some other law that forbids this, I see no reason why you can’t (even more reasons why I think you can a bit later).

    Because of this silence of the laws, it’s probably wise to put any important procedures such as this into your by-laws. You’ll want to cover such things as quorum, rules of order, and electronic participation.

    What about Robert’s Rules?

    Since the civil code appears to be silent, what about the main North American authority on meetings: Robert’s Rules of Order.

    The latest edition of Robert’s Rules accepts the 21st century, and allows modern technology in meetings. Their main requirement is that whatever technology is used, must let everyone taking part hear each other at the same time and, in the case of a videoconference, see each other as well. They say that simultaneous communication amongst all participants is “central to the deliberative character of a meeting.” It recognizes both videoconferencing and teleconferencing technologies, but recommends their use be included in the organization’s by-laws.

    However, they warn that although e-mail or fax are fine for issuing calls for meetings, or for voting by ballot, these technologies, unlike conferencing, aren’t suitable for carrying out the business of a meeting because of the lack of real-time interaction amongst all participants.

    As far as electronic participation is concerned, your by-laws should say, at a minimum:

    • members can attend in person, by teleconference, by video conference, or any other method that allows simultaneous communication amongst all participants;
    • electronic participation counts towards quorum; and
    • electronic participants can vote.

    What’s the general acceptance in Mexico of this technology?

    In 2005, UNCITRAL (United Nations Commission on International Trade Law) has been encouraging countries to incorporate electronic signatures and electronic mediums into their laws. Since 2006 or so, Mexico has been embracing a world trend in letting conference technology be used in meetings. It’s important to note that any international agreements signed by Mexico have the same weight as Federal Law.

    Apart from major corporations who routinely use this technology for meetings, I’ve looked at the laws governing two federal departments (chosen at random). Both the Consejo Nacional de Ciencia y Tecnologia (National Council of Science and Technology) and the Consejo Nacional de Evaluacion de la Politica de Desarrollo Social (National Council for Evaluation of Social Development Policy) allow videoconferencing technology. Here’s an excerpt from the statutes regulating the last of these two councils (Article 22.- Attendance):

    In special cases, members of the Executive Board will be able to attend the ordinary and extraordinary sessions of the Executive Board in a virtual way, through videoconference or other similar medium that lets them analyse, suggest, and discuss in real time the business of the session and the choices for the solution of problems.

    Further, there are significant changes being made to the legal system by Federal legislation to let videoconferencing technology be used in courts. This is particularly true of those courts that deal with business and commercial disputes. For example, the Tribunal Federal de Justicia Fiscal y Administrativa (Federal Court of Fiscal and Administrative Justice) has allowed videoconference testimony since at least 2009.

    The 2012 version of the Código De Comercio (the federal Code of Commercial Law) lets videoconference testimony be used in judicial hearings for matters falling under this code’s jurisdiction.

    If it’s acceptable to the federal government, I don’t see why your condo can’t do it.

    What about condo assemblies?

    Since use of this technology appears to be possible for board and committee meetings, what about a condo assembly?

    Again, the condo law is silent. In Jalisco. Interestingly, the condo law in the state of Quintana Roo specifically lets participation in a condo assembly take place by videoconference. Their condo law says that for voting in an assembly, electronic voting and communications can be used for owners who aren’t present.

    For a large condo with a high number of absentees, the technical issues could be overwhelming, but there doesn’t appear to be a legal impediment. In such a case, this might be impractical at the present time, but a few years in the future…

    Personally, I’d rather attend a meeting or an assembly by conferencing than by proxy. Why would you allow one and not the other? What’s the difference in concept, apart from the technology and the superior ability to take part in the discussions with conferencing?

    This last section about assemblies is bound to be a bit controversial, so let’s hear your thoughts…

  • Accepting Proxies at an Assembly

    Correction to the “Jalisco Condo Manual”

    On page 268 of the “Jalisco Condo Manual,” I say that before you can use proxies, you must add the ability to use them to your by-laws. This is not correct!

    You Can’t Refuse a Legal Proxy!

    It’s important to know that you cannot refuse a legally valid proxy at an assembly.

    This is because a proxy is a power of attorney.

    A Power of Attorney is a legal document, and it must be accepted. The person it names as a representive must be allowed to carry out any action specifically set out in the document on behalf of the person giving the power, as long as the person giving the power would themselves be allowed to take such action.

    Powers of Attorney are regulated by Book Four, Second Part, Title Nine of the Jalisco Civil Code (included in the “Jalisco Condo Law in English”).

    Article 2204 talks about three types of power of attorney documents:

    • publicly registered;
    • private, but signatures verified by a notario; and
    • private, without verification of signatures by a notario.

    This last one would seem to apply to most proxies.

    What’s Needed to Make a Proxy Legal?

    It must clearly say that a specific person (the person giving the proxy) is giving powers to a specific person (the person who’ll use the proxy) for a specific purpose (voting their condo rights) for a specific event (a specific condo assembly).

    It can give general powers (the proxy holder votes as they choose), or it can give specific instructions as to how the votes must be cast (a limited proxy).

    Because this is a legal document, it must be in Spanish.

    Article 70 says that the person giving the proxy must sign it, print their name, and have two witness signatures.

    It’s also important to know that the person acting for an owner by proxy doesn’t have to be an owner, or to even live in the condo. The proxy holder can be their abogado, property manager, a relative, or a friend. This person is allowed by the document to exercise the owner’s condo rights at the assembly in their place, as if they were that owner.

    Accepting Faxed or Emailed Proxies

    Accepting proxies by email or fax is convenient for owners who are away during the time of the assembly, and it’s certainly more practical (and inclusive) to do this. Fortunately, this seems to be supported by legislation.

    Article 1308 is the section that requires signatures on contracts (powers of attorney fall under this category).

    This article also specifically allows “electronic, optical, certified electronic signature, or any other technology mediums, if and when the information is generated or communicated wholly by means of the aforementioned mediums, [the signatures] can be attributed to the obligated people, [the documents] will exist permanently, and they will be accessible for further examination [the proxy form must be kept in the condo records and must not be destroyed].”

    This acceptance of contract documents by electronic media was added to the Jalisco Civil Code in September of 2006. I believe the goal was to bring Mexico in line with other countries in acknowledging the digital age.

    Most common law jurisdictions have recognised a faxed signature as legal since the 1980’s (actually, this was preceded by the legal acceptance of telegraphed signatures in the late 1800’s!). Today, courts in many US and Canadian jurisdictions have ruled that legally enforceable electronic signatures can now include: agreements made by email or fax; signing a credit or debit slip with a digital pen device at the time of sale; signing electronic documents online, and even entering a PIN into a bank machine.

    Properties Bought by Bank Trust

    On the coast, where property bought by foreigners must be held in trust by a bank, a slightly different situation exists.

    The condo law only lets the registered titleholder of the property vote at an assembly. In the case of a bank trust, the bank is the registered titleholder. Some trust agreements give the foreign buyer the right to exercise the condo rights at an assembly, others don’t.

    For foreign buyers where this is the case, the condo must have a copy of their trust agreement on file showing that they have this ability. Note that this power isn’t normally transferable, unless it specifically says so in the trust agreement. Therefore, these buyers cannot normally give a proxy to someone else.

    Foreign buyers who don’t have this provision in their agreement will need a Power of Attorney from the bank giving them the right to vote at the assembly.

    If either type of buyer can’t attend, they can ask the bank to give a Power of Attorney to a third party.

    Again, you cannot refuse a power of attorney, and the holder doesn’t need to be an owner or resident of the condo.

    Have a Standardised Proxy Policy

    I still recommend that you have a proxy policy set out in your by-laws. This avoids confusion, and helps reduce questions and challenges.

    I recommend that this policy says, at a minimum:

    • you accept proxies for your assemblies;
    • they count towards quorum;
    • you accept them by fax and email;
    • briefly what the minimum requirements for a valid proxy are; and
    • to whom they must be delivered, and a cut-off (usually the day before the assembly).

    I also recommend you use a standard proxy form that you send to all owners with the assembly call package (I give you a sample form in the BONUS Pack that comes with the “Jalisco Condo Manual”). The main reason for doing this is to make it much easier to verify the legality of each proxy. Imagine your scrutineers having to check a number of completely different forms just before the assembly. If you use your own form, they can verify them more quickly.

    Over to You

    If you have specific experience with accepting or rejecting proxies at a condo assembly, please share them in the comment section below this post. If you have a comment or a legal opinion relating to this topic, please share it below. If you prefer your comments or stories to be anonymous and unattributed, please use the “Email Us” tab on the left of this page to send us a private email.

  • Can Delinquent Owners Vote at an Assembly?

    The controversy

    I think I might have chosen a controversial topic for my first blog post, but I’ve received questions about this topic from multiple condos both on the coast and in the Lake Chapala area, and I think it’s an important one!

    On page 37 of the “Jalisco Condo Manual” I wrote, “It isn’t legal to prevent an owner from voting at an assembly for any reason, including if they’re late in paying fees or assessments.”

    This post has been updated since it was first published with an opinion from a notario (see “A conclusion…” at the end).

    So, how did I come up with this?

    I based this partly on a legal opinion that our condo got when we were planning our first assembly to change the administration from the developer to the owners several years ago. The developer had forbidden delinquent owners from being at and voting at the assemblies, and the transition team wanted to know if this was legal. The legal opinion they got said that it was not. Unfortunately, this opinion wasn’t in writing.

    As well as this legal opinion, the opinion in my book was based on some reasoning:

    The condo law doesn’t set up categories of owners – it just defines owners (or, more correctly, condóminos or title holders). These owners are then given rights and obligations by the condo law.

    This can be interpreted as meaning that an owner is an owner, whether blue, four-feet tall, or delinquent.

    There’s nothing in the Code to suggest that a condo owner loses their inherent rights just because they’re behind on their fees. I believe that the right to be at a condo assembly, and to vote is a real right that’s attached to the title of each condo unit.

    • The section of the Code on owners’ rights and responsibilities does not qualify that these rights only apply when an owner is current.
    • The section on assemblies simply refers to owners attending and voting, and does not in any way qualify this.
    • The section that explicitly deals with the remedy for non-payment of fees does not mention that delinquent owners can be stopped from voting at an assembly (if this were the intent of the legislation, I’d expect something to be found here).

    Summary: since the Code gives explicit rights to owners (and I believe that property owners also have more rights under other sections of the Code), and since it doesn’t appear to lessen or change these rights when the owner becomes delinquent in their fees, I don’t believe that a lesser authority (such as the by-laws or a Council/Board) can override these fundamental rights.

    Another compelling argument was brought up by a commenter below: if your delinquent owners together have 26% or more of the condo rights, and you bar them from voting at assemblies, then you can never hold an extraordinary assembly (because you can never get the minimum 75% of the total condo rights needed to pass a motion).

    Dueling lawyers

    I’ve been told by various condos that they have legal opinions from local abogados telling them that they can and that they cannot prevent delinquent owners from voting at an assembly. Yes, you read that correctly… there are conflicting, polar opposite opinions out there.

    The problem is that none of these opinions are in writing, nor are there any citations. By citations, I mean that the lawyer says you can do this because of Article xxx of the Code, or the Ley de Blahblahblah, Article yyy. Without this, it’s impossible to know if they’re just off-the-cuff opinions (that might not be correct), or a fact of law.

    If I were on a Council/Board of a condo that was planning to enact a policy to take away a fundamental right of an owner, I’d want to have a very clear legal position to back this action up.

    Without this legal backup, I’d strongly recommend erring on the side of caution. I wouldn’t try to stop an owner voting at an assembly because they’re delinquent in their fees, unless I had a detailed (includes citations) written legal opinion from a Mexican legal professional supporting this action.

    A challenge to the community

    This is a controversial and important topic. I, for one, would like a definitive answer. If I see something concrete, I’m more than ready to change my position on this.

    So… if any of you out there have a definitive legal opinion on this, please share it in the comment section below this post! If you’ve prevented morosos from voting, and have run afoul of a lawsuit or other legal problem, please also share your story! If you prefer your comments or stories to be anonymous and unattributed, please use the “Email Us” tab on the left of this page to send us a private email.

    With the breadth of experience in the condo community in Jalisco, maybe we can all get a conclusive answer on this. Community interaction is one of the reasons I started this blog…

    A conclusion… [Update]

    I have received an email from a Jalisco notario whom I respect very much. He says that a formal legal opinion on this issue should not be needed because voting at an assembly is a basic right of condo owners. He adds that if a condo has an issue with unpaid fees, it must be dealt with in a law suit, and can never be used as an excuse to deny voting rights.